Tuesday’s Mystery Lineup: Murder, She Wrote Reigns, Aurora Teagarden & More
If you’re hunting for a Tuesday that keeps you on the edge of your seat, “GREAT! Mystery” has a lineup that’s hard to ignore. From classic sleuthing to fresh twists, the channel delivers a mix of familiar favourites and newer thrills.
08:00 – 08:10 Good News on GREAT! Extra
A brief pause with uplifting stories that remind us the world can still shine. It’s a light‑hearted break before the investigations kick off.
Not a mystery, but it’s a necessary palate cleanser.
08:10 – 09:06 An Aurora Teagarden Mystery: Lesson In Murder
…Lesson In Murder: Whether the police like it or not, budding sleuth Aurora is soon on the case when a student from her true crime literature class is murdered. (2024)
The pacing is steady, and Aurora’s curiosity keeps the plot moving. Still entertaining for fans of cozy mysteries.
09:06 – 09:11 Good News on GREAT!
A quick five‑minute recap that keeps the optimism flowing.
A nice spot for a quick recharge.
09:11 – 10:00 An Aurora Teagarden Mystery: Lesson In Murder (continued)
…Lesson In Murder: The second part unravels the mystery further, keeping viewers hooked.
A solid continuation that maintains the series’ charm.
10:00 – 11:00 Murder, She Wrote – The Error Of Her Ways (S6 Ep4)
In Palm Springs, Jessica teams up with the local chief of police to figure out who killed a local investor and what happened to a large amount of money.
A classic formula that still holds up, offering a touch of nostalgia.
11:00 – 12:00 Murder, She Wrote – Jack And Bill (S6 Ep5)
Jessica narrates the story of an ex‑football player turned private eye who investigates the murder of his old teammate with the help of a savvy pooch.
The quirky detective duo brings a lightness that balances the darker moments.
12:00 – 13:00 Unforgettable – About Face (S4 Ep11)
A homeless man’s accidental death exposes a kidnapping and murder that lead Carrie and Al to investigate a construction company’s ties to a multi‑state crime spree.
The twist on the crime‑family narrative keeps it from feeling stale.
13:00 – 14:00 In Plain Sight – The Anti‑Social Network (S5 Ep1)
Mary returns from maternity leave and is assigned to protect a witness who could destroy a powerful secret society.
The intrigue is solid, and Mary’s return adds an extra layer of tension.
14:00 – 15:00 Castle – The Wrong Stuff (S7 Ep16)
When an astronaut is mysteriously killed during a simulated mission to Mars, Castle and Beckett spacesuit‑up and investigate.
The sci‑fi twist provides a fun departure from the usual crime‑scene.
15:00 – 16:00 Diagnosis Murder – Murder on Thin Ice (S5 Ep3)
Will Steve, Amanda and Dr Sloan get an icy reception when they investigate the murder of a figure skater?
The setting adds a chilling atmosphere that keeps the episode interesting.
16:00 – 17:00 Diagnosis Murder – X Marks the Murder (S5 Ep4)
Part 1: Dr Sloan is drawn into an investigation when he is contacted by a serial murderer known as the Casanova Killer.
The mystery deepens, promising a twist in the next episode.
17:00 – 18:00 Murder, She Wrote – Night Of The Headless Horseman (S3 Ep9)
Jessica is in the wrong place at the right time to help her friend Dorian Beecher when he is accused of a murder he didn’t commit.
The classic whodunnit remains reliable.
18:00 – 19:00 Murder, She Wrote – Death Stalks The Big Top – Part 1 (S3 Ep10)
Jessica’s niece receives a silver Leprechaun from someone who has been presumed dead for years.
The circus setting gives a fresh backdrop to the familiar plot.
19:00 – 20:00 Castle – Hong Kong Hustle (S7 Ep17)
Beckett and Castle work with a high‑powered Hong Kong detective to investigate her friend’s murder.
The international angle adds a new flavour to the series.
20:00 – 21:00 Unforgettable – Bad Company (S4 Ep12)
Capt. Russo is suspected in the murder of an informant, leading Carrie and Al into a deadly game of cat-and‑mouse with a corrupt former cop.
The stakes feel higher than ever.
21:00 – 22:00 In Plain Sight – Four Marshals and a Baby (S5 Ep2)
Mary scrambles to find childcare while working on a case in which a hoarder witnessed a murder.
The balance between personal and professional keeps it grounded.
22:00 – 22:56 True Justice – About Face (S4 Ep1)
Crime drama with Katherine McNamara. After her brother is convicted of murder, a law student sets out to prove his innocence.
The premise is fresh, with a strong female lead.
22:56 – 23:01 Good News on GREAT!
Another quick burst of positivity before the night deepens.
A pleasant pause.
23:01 – 23:55 True Justice – About Face (S4 Ep2)
The investigation deepens, and danger escalates as the truth comes closer.
The suspense remains credible.
23:55 – 00:51 Lost Letter Mysteries – From The Heart (S1 Ep1)
Light‑hearted drama starring Eric Mabius. Oliver and his team uncover a 200‑year‑old Valentine’s letter that could change history.
The premise is charming, though the pace could feel uneven.
00:51 – 00:56 Good News on GREAT!
Another brief segment of optimism.
A quick recharge before the next set.
00:56 – 01:50 Lost Letter Mysteries – From The Heart (S1 Ep2)
Continuing the quest for the century‑old letter, the stakes rise.
The drama keeps the audience interested.
01:50 – 03:30 Fatal Flatline
Thriller starring Julie McNiven. A grieving couple donates their dead daughter’s organs. The recipient of her heart exhibits a disturbing obsession.
The psychological tension is strong, though the plot may feel familiar.
03:30 – 05:00 The Killer Downstairs
Disturbing thriller starring Cindy Busby. Alison thinks she’s won the tenancy lottery when the seemingly perfect James moves into her basement.
The tension escalates as house rules are threatened.
05:00 – 05:30 Teleshopping
A quick interlude of commercial offers.
05:30 – 06:00 Teleshopping
Another brief advertising segment.
Bottom line: The Tuesday lineup on GREAT! Mystery offers a solid blend of classic and contemporary mysteries, with Murder, She Wrote as the standout anchor. Aurora Teagarden and Unforgettable provide fresh angles, while the late‑night thrillers keep the adrenaline going. A well‑rounded schedule for mystery lovers.
Related Content