If you’re worth your salt in movie knowledge and critique, then you could probably tell that “Legends of Oz: Dorothy’s Return” was going to be rough just from the commercials. But just how terrible is it? Well, according to the critics, it’s about as bad as you can imagine a 3D-animated “sequel” to the original 1939 live action film could be.
Critics weren’t shy about what they thought about”Legends of Oz: Dorothy’s Return.” “As unnecessary, uninspired ‘Wizard o Oz’ revivals go…this 3-D animated off-brand tale isn’t exactly wicked–it’s just a little short on brains,” wrote Entertainment Weekly’s Adam Markovitz. “…[T]here’s barely a trace of the magic in 1939′s ‘The Wizard of Oz.’”
The New York Times’ Nicolas Rapold said that certain creative touches were interesting, “[b]ut fine details like these must be picked out from among more slipshod visuals, much as the one-liners are lost int he wash of generic back-and-forth and week characterizations.”
Newsday’s Rafer Guzmán called the film “[s]tiffly animated, slugglishly directed…and padded out with generic Broadway-rock tunes co-written by Bryan Adams” and also said that it feels like it “has no heart.”
The film also received a very low 14 percent rating on Rotten Tomatoes, but mentioning that is only rubbing salt in the wound.
Want to know what we thought about the film? Take a look at the review written by ShockYa’s Karen Benardello. What do you think of “Legends of Oz: Dorothy’s Return”? Discuss in the comments section!