
WAILUKU, Hawaii — John Pelletier walks into the Maui Police Commission on Wednesday asking for his job back, and could walk out on the way to being Maui’s ex-chief. Six weeks after the commission voted 6-0 to put him on paid leave, its closed-session agenda “appears intended to lay the groundwork for firing” him, a Honolulu Civil Beat column reported. The county charter lets the commission remove a chief only for cause, after formal charges and a public hearing, so Wednesday is where that case either starts or stalls.
In the commissioners’ file is an email Pelletier sent on May 24, 2022, at 1:49 p.m., answering a complaint about illegal cockfights. “Aloha, we will look into it and see what we can do,” Pelletier wrote, and copied Randy Esperanza, then his assistant chief for investigative services.
John Pelletier is no stranger to controversy. He was the Las Vegas incident commander at the Route 91 shooting in 2017 and the Maui police chief when 102 people died in Lahaina in 2023, where survivors said police barricades turned cars back toward the fire, a charge he disputes. Three of his own employees sued the department in 2023, alleging retaliation and a hostile workplace. In March 2025 he was named in Ashley Parham’s federal lawsuit against Sean “Diddy” Combs, which accused him of helping cover up an alleged 2018 gang rape. Two months after he was named, it was reported that fellow officers spared him a breathalyzer after a single-car crash near his home. Then in August 2026 the FBI arrested the lieutenant who ran his Criminal Intelligence Unit, a unit that reported directly to him, on charges of selling police protection to cockfighters and drug traffickers. The Maui Police Commission put Pelletier on paid leave on Oct. 7.
“Received a few complaints and folks are pretty scared of the police on this as well, they won’t even tell me their names.”
Is Pelletier Dirty, Stupid, or Both? 2022 Letter “A Smoking Gun”
The email is part of a five-page packet mailed to the commission as testimony, stamped received Nov. 17. Maui commentator Jeni, of YouTube’s Connect the Dots with Jeni, posted the pages and called it “a smoking gun.” We have reviewed all five, posted by the county as public correspondence for Wednesday’s agenda.
Page one is an anonymous letter to the mayor, police chief, commission and council, stamped by the council office May 12, 2022. A Kahakuloa resident reports that “the first illegal chicken fighting event” was held March 27, 2022, on Kahekili Highway and “continues every Sunday.” “Multiple calls to the police have been made with zero action occurring.”
Twelve days later someone whose name is redacted forwarded it to Pelletier. The note says a party whose name is also redacted “received a few complaints and folks are pretty scared of the police on this as well, they won’t even tell me their names.” Pelletier replied 32 minutes later.
Did Pelletier Know About or Was He Involved in Lt. Vaituulala’s Crimes?
It proves that Pelletier was personally told, five months into the job, that cockfights ran weekly, that calls to his department went nowhere, and that residents feared his officers. He acknowledged it and copied a senior commander.
Jeni’s caption says Pelletier knew “that MPD was involved”; the email says people were scared of the police.
Four years later the FBI arrested Lt. Michael Vaituulala, whose Criminal Intelligence Unit reported directly to Pelletier, on a complaint alleging he sold police protection to both cockfighters and drug traffickers: cockfight organizers paid him a cut of their proceeds to tell officers which fights to leave alone, a drug seller covered his bar tabs, and he passed traffickers evidence photos, the identities of confidential sources and word of a sealed federal wiretap, Civil Beat reported.
Pelletier said then that he was “disappointed, shocked, upset.” The commission put him on leave Oct. 7 to investigate his oversight of that unit.
Pelletier Litigation is Costing Maui Tax Payers a Fortune
In a Nov. 17 video Jeni attacked a submission she attributes to Keisa Liu, who defended the chief in a Civil Beat op-ed, estimating the leave could cost taxpayers $130,000. Jeni countered with her own ledger: council resolutions on four employment suits against the department, each above the $25,000 that requires council approval; a mortuary contractor’s claim of nearly $280,000 for Lahaina fire work; and a special-counsel contract capped at $500,000.
In a Nov. 14 video she said she “got word” that Acting Chief Wade Maeda told officers Pelletier promoted to testify for him. She went further, calling Maeda a known drunk, alleging he once hit a car while under the influence and asking whether he paid to make it go away. Maeda has not publicly addressed them.
Pelletier Lied About “Bissen’s Felonious Crime?” Subversive Behavior
Jeni’s newest post goes after Pelletier’s own defense. Since the Oct. 7 vote Pelletier has said he was benched because Mayor Richard Bissen is under criminal investigation, a claim Bissen denies and the county prosecutor has refuted. In a post headlined as “the paper trail that shows Pelletier LIED,” Jeni published a two-page letter she says the commission uploaded for Wednesday’s meeting. Dated Oct. 1, 2026, it is from Prosecuting Attorney Andrew Martin to Council Chair Alice Lee, and Bissen himself signed it “approved for transmittal” the next day.
Martin writes that his office learned in August 2024 of allegations before the Board of Ethics about “an individual within the Office of Economic Development,” and in January 2025 “opened a criminal investigation into the possible misuse of County grant funds.” The state attorney general’s Special Investigation and Prosecution Division joined, and in March 2026 Martin handed it all prosecutorial decisions so the findings would be “beyond reproach.”
The investigation, he writes, “remains an active and ongoing” one. The letter cuts both ways. It names an employee of an office under the mayor, not the mayor, which is Jeni’s point. It also confirms, six days before the commission moved on Pelletier, that a criminal probe of the mayor’s administration is real, was taken out of local hands, and is not finished. It does not say who the targets are, and it clears no one.
Pelletier’s attack on Mayor Bissen looks like one more failed attempt to undermine Hawaii’s elected leaders and the government they run.
Serious Allegations Against John Pelletier
Jeni has been early in much of her reporting. Our May 2025 report on Pelletier’s single-vehicle crash into a ditch was first reported by Jeni, who alleged he had been drinking with fellow officers and that a patrol officer sent to breathalyze him was shouted down. Pelletier was never charged and never addressed it.
The March 2025 amended complaint in Parham v. Combs, the Sean “Diddy” Combs suit, accused Pelletier, then a Las Vegas Metro Police captain, of appearing after Ashley Parham’s alleged 2018 gang rape in Orinda, California, posing as a sheriff’s officer and handing a neighbor an envelope of cash; two co-plaintiffs alleged he abducted them at gunpoint. Judge Rita Lin dismissed the case in December 2025 for failure to prosecute, without prejudice. It can be refiled.
A source we spoke to alleged that Pelletier took part in the rapes and saying he was reported to law enforcement as a participant. Pelletier called every claim in the lawsuit false and claims he was in Las Vegas.
Sources: Testimony packet to the Maui Police Commission for its Nov. 18, 2026 meeting (anonymous letter stamped May 12, 2022; email chain dated May 24, 2022; envelopes postmarked May 10, 2022 and Nov. 13, 2026), posted at mauicounty.gov; Connect the Dots with Jeni, YouTube community post (Nov. 17, 2026) and videos (Nov. 14 and Nov. 17, 2026); Honolulu Civil Beat (Nov. 15-16, 2026; Oct. 7, 2026; Aug. 6, 2026; Dec. 2025; March 19, 2025); Hawaii News Now (Nov. 6, 2026); The Maui News (March 2022); Maui Now (March 19, 2025); United States v. Vaituulala, D. Haw., criminal complaint; Parham v. Combs, No. 3:24-cv-07191 (N.D. Cal.), amended complaint (March 7, 2025) and order dismissing for failure to prosecute (Dec. 16, 2025); Paul Smith’s interviews and reporting at Shockya. This is an opinion article.
Related coverage
- Pelletier in alleged car accident coverup was “driving intoxicated”
- Mob connected Maui Police Chief John Pelletier in free fall
- Civil Beat: Maui Police Commission’s secret agenda to deal with its outspoken chief
- Civil Beat: High-ranking Maui cop accused of protecting cockfights, drug dealers for cash

